The UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) recently unveiled its Annual Report and Accounts for the year ending March 2023, providing insights into its strategic advancements and the dynamic landscape of financial regulation. This report is the first lens through which to gauge the strides made within the context of the FCA's three-year strategy, introduced in April 2022 and further elaborated in its annual business plan.
While the report and the correlated enforcement statistics underscore an increasingly proactive regulator, they also spotlight a burgeoning backlog of investigations, prompting calls for additional resources to address the extensive array of responsibilities that the FCA grapples with.
Sharpened Focus on Financial Crime
In an effort to optimize resource allocation, the FCA disclosed in April 2023 its intention to direct any supplemental resources toward four of its 13 prioritized areas:
Prioritizing consumers' needs
Preparing financial services for future challenges
Diminishing and preventing financial crime
Reinforcing the UK's standing in global wholesale markets
The FCA's concentrated endeavours to curb and thwart financial crime have entailed fortifying its authorization process, elevating assessments of regulated entities, and augmenting staffing levels dedicated to probing and prosecuting financial misconduct.
As part of this commitment, the FCA has established a dedicated fraud team, which has instituted an internal framework to evaluate firms' anti-fraud systems and controls.
Empowered Approach to Authorization
These initiatives have yielded favourable outcomes. Investments in human capital and technology have led to an almost 60% reduction in the backlog of pending authorization cases, despite heightened scrutiny of authorization applications. In the financial year concluding March 2023, the FCA turned down 24% of applications, a notable increase from 21% the preceding year and 7% in the year ending March 2021, facilitated by the creation of a dedicated authorizations intelligence team.
A significant factor driving the heightened rejection rate is the rigorous criteria for authorizing crypto asset businesses; only 7% of such applications resulted in successful authorization. Collaborating with law enforcement agencies, the FCA participated in curbing illegal crypto activities, including supporting an investigation that led to restraining orders involving over £3 million in crypto assets in November 2022.
Beyond a more rigorous approach to authorizations, the FCA has also focused on mitigating the risk posed by already authorized firms. This effort has led to a 30% surge in the number of firms having their authorizations revoked and a 34% uptick in alerts stemming from potentially illicit online activity.
The FCA's commitment to technological advancement remains steadfast as it continues to enhance its market oversight responsibilities, implementing a new Market Surveillance system set to be fully operational by October 2023.
Assessing Progress and Challenges
Assessing the tangible impact of the FCA's measures to curb fraud and financial crime is a complex undertaking. While reported victims of fraud witnessed a 3.5% decline year-on-year according to the National Fraud and Intelligence Bureau (NFIB), actual losses surged by 6.8%. This does, however, mark a considerable deceleration compared to the preceding year's growth rate of 53%.
The market's perception of the FCA's effectiveness is a mixed bag. In the 2022/23 FCA and Practitioner Panel Survey, 50% of firms expressed that market abuse remains a concern in the UK, and only 60% considered the FCA to be effective in fostering market integrity and safeguarding against delayed or misleading disclosures, insider dealing, and market manipulation.
This nuanced view is echoed in the FCA's enforcement statistics. While fines handed to individuals tripled over the past year to 9, the overall value of fines issued to both firms and individuals declined from £313 million to £215.8 million.
The FCA has noticeably amplified the exercise of its investigatory powers, initiating 613 new financial crime supervision cases over the year—a 10% increase from its 2021 baseline and a 65% surge from 2022. The FCA commenced 158 interventions cases in 2022/23, up from 142 the prior year. Moreover, it initiated 51 cases using its own initiative powers, a rise from 35 the preceding year.
While the FCA's proactive stance is evident, it grapples with the duration of investigations. The average duration of criminal investigations undertaken by the FCA swelled in 2022/23 to 59 months—nearly double the duration recorded in the prior year. Factoring in the average nine-month length of the resolution or litigation phase of a criminal case, defendants now face an average span of over five and a half years from the initiation of an investigation to final resolution.
The FCA's ongoing evolution underscores both achievements and challenges, revealing the complexity of its mission in navigating a rapidly changing financial landscape. As the FCA continues to evolve, stakeholders will keenly watch its strategies to foster market integrity and protect against financial misconduct in an increasingly interconnected and complex financial environment.
Comments